Electronic driver aids are now a fixture of modern cars. Since 2024, the European Union has required key safety systems in new vehicles. But having those features on the equipment list is one thing; making them useful is another.
Modern cars are hard to imagine without electronic driver aids. But listing those features on a spec sheet is very different from making them work well enough that drivers won't switch them off five minutes into a trip. Britain's Auto Express put seven vehicles through an extensive test to find out which systems genuinely help—and which mostly irritate.
Auto Express evaluated seven current models on a demanding route of roughly 37 miles. The test had two parts: first, driver-assistance systems that issue warnings or intervene, followed by Level 2 driving assistance that can control steering and speed on highways under driver supervision. Scores from both categories determined the final ranking.
1. BMW iX3: The benchmark
BMW's electric crossover, built on the new Neue Klasse platform, scored 39 out of a possible 41 points. It never misread a speed limit, and its electronics automatically slowed or accelerated to stay within the posted limit. Driver monitoring was unusually unobtrusive. When the driver deliberately changed lanes safely, the car neither sounded shrill warnings nor fought for control of the steering wheel. Level 2 assistance engaged and disengaged smoothly, and the display always made clear whether the driver or the system was steering. There wasn't a single unnecessary beep throughout the drive. It delivered the balance other manufacturers are still trying to find.
2. Volvo EX60: Safe, but complicated
Volvo took second place, backing up the brand's safety reputation. Driver monitoring and lane-keeping assistance worked accurately and discreetly. Just one misread speed-limit sign kept the EX60 from matching the BMW. The Swedish crossover lost ground in the Level 2 assistance portion, however. Activating Pilot Assist required a complicated sequence of switch inputs that was difficult to figure out without the manual. Automatic lane changes were temperamental, too: the car would suggest a pass, then cancel the maneuver while carrying it out. Volvo attributes this behavior to its philosophy of keeping the driver involved. There's merit to that approach, but the execution still left the testers frustrated.
3. Ford Puma Gen-E: Best on the highway
The Ford Puma Gen-E's equipment includes BlueCruise, a system that allows hands-free highway driving. On the highway, it worked well. The car held its lane confidently, maintained its following distance, and displayed a blue steering-wheel symbol in the instrument cluster. Off the highway, the experience became much less relaxing. The Puma reacted anxiously to even moderately sharp curves, issuing repeated warnings and demanding driver intervention. On rural roads, it created more commotion than assistance. Its 31-point score reflected that narrow focus.
4. Volkswagen T-Roc: A pleasant surprise, with caveats
The T-Roc finished second in the Level 2 assistance category. It handled the first challenging bend with surprising confidence, slowing itself to 25 mph. Its interface was straightforward: MODE, SET, and RES buttons made operation easy to understand without opening the manual. The T-Roc also performed well on the highway, but its automatic lane-change function never worked. The driver tried eight times, yet the car kept asking for attention to the road. It also did not always respond correctly to changes in the speed limit. The result was 31 points and fourth place.
5. Tesla Model Y: Its way or the highway
Tesla's approach to sharing steering duties proved inflexible: when the driver tried to help steer, the system disengaged. That happened 11 times during the test. The Model Y performed well on the highway. Automatic lane changes worked smoothly: activate the turn signal, and the car eased into the next lane. On winding rural roads, however, the steering became unnaturally heavy, the camera-based system sometimes guided the car too close to the road's edge, and it misinterpreted speed limits in built-up areas. It finished fifth with 28 points.
6. Jaecoo 7: A barrage of warnings
If there were an award for the most irritating driver aids, the Jaecoo 7 would have won easily. It issued about 100 warnings during an hour of driving. It flagged lane departures that hadn't happened, accused the driver of being distracted when they were simply checking the instruments, and struggled with speed limits. Its behavior in curves was unpredictable: sometimes it drifted too close to the road's edge; at other times, it crossed the centerline. A Jaecoo representative later explained that the intelligent cruise control is calibrated for highways, is not intended to replace the driver, and disengages when operating conditions fall outside its parameters. On the narrow roads of Northamptonshire, where the test took place, it disengaged repeatedly. The result was 15 points and sixth place.
7. Leapmotor B10: Last by a wide margin
The Chinese-built Leapmotor B10 electric vehicle finished last with eight points. Lane-keeping assistance performed poorly: the car alternately detected and lost the lane markings, wandered within its lane, and required excessive steering effort to correct. At roundabouts, the B10 persistently tried to take the first exit. Eventually, the test driver lost patience and switched off the assistance systems to finish the drive back to base without them. That was perhaps the clearest verdict of all.
The takeaway
The gap between the best and worst performers was enormous: 39 points for BMW versus eight for Leapmotor. The article's assessment is that the problem lies not in the hardware, but in software and calibration.
BMW and Volvo demonstrated that electronic assistance can be unobtrusive yet effective. Some manufacturers, by contrast, still seem to treat installing sensors and cameras as sufficient, with real-world behavior an afterthought. That approach does little for the driver.