Modern Hyundai vehicles are generally considered reliable and long-lasting. Many rack up six-figure mileage without major mechanical problems.
Modern Hyundai vehicles are generally considered reliable and long-lasting. Many rack up six-figure mileage without major mechanical problems, but two engines in the automaker’s history seriously damaged its reputation for reliability. Jalopnik recently named them among the least reliable four-cylinder engines ever built.
The engines in question belong to the Theta II gasoline engine family, which until recently was a key part of both Hyundai’s and Kia’s engine lineups.
The Theta family debuted in the mid-2000s, developed by Hyundai as a modern line of four-cylinder gasoline engines. The engines later saw widespread use in Hyundai and Kia vehicles, including the Sonata, Optima and other models. The Theta II version with GDI direct injection became one of the family’s best-known variants—and one of its least reliable.
Particularly serious problems emerged in the 2.0-liter and 2.4-liter engines. Metal debris from crankshaft machining remained inside some engines during manufacturing. Over time, that debris could interfere with connecting-rod bearing operation, causing accelerated wear and damage.
In 2015, Hyundai announced a recall covering about 470,000 Sonata vehicles from the 2011–2012 model years. Owners were advised to watch for unusual engine knocking and an illuminated check-engine light.
In some cases, the failure caused the engine to seize while the vehicle was being driven. Problems appeared at widely varying mileages, but the average was around 24,000 miles.
The defect drew widespread attention and had major financial consequences for the manufacturers. Hyundai and Kia subsequently reached a settlement worth about $1.3 billion.
In 2020, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) also announced penalties against the two companies totaling $210 million.
The problems took a heavy toll on the automakers’ finances and reputations. Many buyers have since deliberately avoided Hyundai and Kia vehicles, fearing similar problems with their current engines.